I’m not exactly the most consistent blogger when it comes to writing reviews for the bulk of the books I read. Unfortunately, the perfectionist in me often means it takes a good while to write something that I’m happy to publish. As I’ve mentioned in the past, I find it especially hard to review books I really enjoyed or absolutely loved. Let’s be honest, having a whinge about something is always going to be simpler – it’s why angry customers are more likely to review businesses. Putting into words why something was so enjoyable or resonated so deeply with me can be difficult, especially if I’m having trouble narrowing down the exact reasoning. To put it bluntly, there are books for which I am simply not a good enough writer to accurately capture the magic they created in a thousand-ish word review. And I’m cool with that. So, for this week’s TTT topic freebie, here are ten books that were great but simply beyond my abilities to properly review in the way I would have wanted to. Who knows, maybe a future re-read will offer me a chance to change things?
The Poppy War Series – R. F. Kuang
I’m almost certain that those who frequent my blog are already aware of how much I love this military fantasy series, and I do. It’s absolutely fantastic. The characters are complex, the narrative is engaging and the world-building is rich. However, these books deal with some extremely heavy themes and ideas at various points during the story – genocide, racism and colonisation, addiction, rape, human experimentation, war violence, PTSD, and so on. These are huge things to try and address well in a review (there are some reviewers who do an amazing job, though). Not to mention the events of the series are inspired by mid-20th-century Chinese history (and culture), particularly the Second-Sino-Japanese War and the Chinese Civil War, periods of history that I’m not very knowledgeable about. For these reasons, I never attempted to review any of the three books in the series – it’s something I’m happy to enjoy but leave detailed explanations of why it’s so amazing to others better able to capture the nuances.
If We Were Villains – M. L. Rio
Man, I love this little, pretentious, dark academia book. It was literally my favourite thing I read in 2021 and yet, NO REVIEW. I made notes as I read through it and upon finishing, I even tried to compile them into something resembling a review, but no matter what I did I couldn’t seem to put my thoughts on the page in the way I wanted to. I think part of the reason I was having such difficulty is because I understood that there was still so much amazingness to IWWV that I was missing due to my lack of experience with some of Shakespeare’s works (and having forgotten the ones I did have experience with). This is one of the few novels I’ve read where I’m genuinely tempted to go back and annotate my copy after having properly researched and analysed its themes, references, and subtext. My inner English student is raring to go! Maybe then, one day, I’ll go back and review it the way it deserves.
The Way of Kings – Brandon Sanderson
In my defense, I actually attempted to write a review for this one. Got a substantial way through, in fact. I even made a joke about the only thing more daunting than starting this book being trying to review it…I mean, it’s over 1000 pages long and so full of EVERYTHING! Every amazing thing you could imagine wanting to talk about with an epic fantasy. The perfectionist demon kicked in and I got overwhelmed, okay? For something this vast and complex, it was difficult to put down what I wanted to say without blabbering inarticulately for the length of a full-blown novella. If there’s one thing I can say it’s that for one of the highest-rated books I’ve seen reviewed on Goodreads with a substantial number of ratings, I definitely understand the hype. It’s justified.
Know My Name – Chanel Miller
Reviewing memoirs and autobiographies is tough to do, especially with a subject matter as tough as this one. I mean, how do I (little, old, boring me) judge another person’s experiences? So, let me just say, this was wonderfully written, powerful, and emotional. How could I possibly hope to capture Chanel’s courage, resilience, and eloquence in one measly 1000-ish word review? I couldn’t and so I didn’t attempt to do so. Solid choice, I think.
.
The Push – Ashley Audrain
I’m so glad my all-over-the-place reading mood was feeling like something thriller-y and discovered this fantastic book at the perfect moment. Although it ended up being more along the lines of a psychological drama, the writing, themes, and characterisation were so wonderfully done that I ate it up completely. As with other books on this list, I once again did take notes as I was making my way through it but when the time came to actually sit down and turn them into a properly worded review, it just wouldn’t click for me. I’m still not sure why. Likely the giant love heart eyes clouding my vision. The mini-review-type summaries included in my favourites of the year list for 2021 and specially dedicated Instagram post mostly cover my thoughts, just in a super abbreviated way. I suppose I’m happy with that for now.
The Heart’s Invisible Furies – John Boyne
Another fantastic book, another mysteriously absent review. I’m noticing a trend with a few of my favourite reads of 2021… Anyway, I’m not quite sure why I never ended up writing a review of this charming, yet sometimes sad, historical novel about a gay man growing up in Ireland. Perhaps because it’s pretty chunky (over 700 pages) and I think I may have been too wrapped up in it to take substantial notes to rely on later. It’s also a somewhat different and quirky sort of read, and I have a feeling I thought I wouldn’t be able to accurately capture all of its great idiosyncracies in a review. Funnily enough, I read Ladder to the Sky the year after, also by Boyne, also rated it highly, and once again didn’t review it. Shame, Ashley, shame!
The Name of the Wind – Patrick Rothfuss
Much like The Way of Kings, this is another example of a chunky-ass fantasy novel that I gave five stars to and never properly reviewed. TNotW was such a great novel, so much so that it cracked my top 10 favourite books the year I read it (and that was a competitive year!). I got swept up in the world, enjoyed the characters, and was taken on an immersive journey. However, this was definitely one of those times where I felt as though others had already said everything I could possibly hope to say about a book and far more articulately than I’d ever manage as well. So I was happy to leave this fabulous (and lengthy) reading experience reviewless.
The Secret History – Donna Tartt
The book that kicked off the literary world’s obsession with dark academia, and deservedly so. TSH is a great read. So, why didn’t I review it, you ask? Well, this book falls under two categories already mentioned in this post: 1) I felt as though I had nothing new to add to the brilliant reviews already in existence for it (I mean, it was published in 1992, after all), and 2) I didn’t understand the ins and outs of it well enough to properly express just how brilliant it was beyond – ohmygod, it was soooo good! I’ll 100% have to give it a re-read at some point down the track and maybe then I’ll revisit it? Until that time, it’s bomb. I get the hype.
Carrie Soto is Back – Taylor Jenkins Reid
Okay, so the worst part about this particular entry on the list is that I made lengthy notes for it (still have them, too). I even intended to sit down and do it! But then I got all wrapped up in my feelings and well, we know how that turned out. Damn it. I think it’s probably because I didn’t read many books in 2022 that I was head over heels for, and this was one of them. Probably was bowled over in shock and joy, even more so because it was a SPORTS book. Who would have guessed? Anyway, I’m holding out hope I’ll finally pen a review for this in the future – if only to gush about TJR, her badass tennis champion Carrie and a wonderful underdog story.
A Darker Shade of Magic Series – V. E. Schwab
Now, this is a bit of a throwback. I used to mention this series a lot but because I haven’t for a while, I feel like it’s okay for it to raise its not-so-ugly head again, especially with Threads of Power coming…eventually. I’m mystified as to how I never reviewed any of the books in this series because I basically made them my whole personality for a while. Might have just been another case of my immense obsession with something overwhelming my ability to produce words articulately. The characters, the worlds, the magic, the story! AHHHHHH, SO GOOD. I’m going to have to reread them before I tackle any new installments and if they aren’t as good as they were years ago, my heart may break. Pray to the reread gods for me, please.
What books left you lost for review-worthy words? Do you struggle to review your most loved reads as much as I do?